Is it better to remove the old floor or install a new one over it?
When it comes to floor renovations, one of the most common questions we get is whether to remove the old floor or lay the new one directly on top. The answer depends on several factors, such as the condition of the existing floor, the material of the new floor, and client preferences. Let’s break down both approaches to help you make the best decision.
Assessing the Existing Floor
The first step is to evaluate the condition of the current floor. We check if it’s level, if there are any damages like cracks or sunken areas, and if the surface is clean enough for the new material to adhere properly.
- If the old floor has significant damage, like cracked tiles or warped wood, it’s best to remove it to avoid issues later on.
- If the floor is in good condition, level, and free of damage, it may be possible to install the new floor directly on top, saving time and costs.
Pros and Cons of Installing Over the Old Floor
Installing a new floor over the existing one has its advantages and disadvantages:
Pros:
- Less mess: Avoids the dust and debris from tearing out the old floor.
- Lower cost: You save on labor and project time.
- Quicker installation: The process is faster.
Cons:
- Raised floor level: This can create issues with doors and baseboards.
- Durability concerns: If the original floor has problems, the new floor may also be affected over time.
- Additional weight: Not all subfloors can handle the extra weight.
Step-by-Step Process
- Inspection and preparation: We evaluate the old floor and clean the surface to ensure good adhesion.
- Leveling: If we decide to install over the old floor, we use a self-leveling compound for a smooth surface.
- Installing the new floor: We lay the new material (tile, laminate, wood) following the manufacturer’s guidelines.
- Final adjustments: We trim doors and adjust baseboards as needed to accommodate the new floor level.
Professional Recommendation
We always recommend consulting a professional to assess the situation and make the best decision. At CCG Contractors, we conduct a thorough inspection to prevent future issues and ensure a high-quality installation.
